Physics, Chemistry, Maths Forum

capacitor tricky

capacitor tricky

by ishaan biswas -
Number of replies: 6

i ahd a doubt::

if we make a circuit consisting of only a capacitor and nothing else. meaning thereby connecting the surfaces of the parallel plates  (the ones which do not form the capacitor) . what happens??

i think that nothing shoul happen but someone told me that it would get instantaneously discharged and there wuld be energy loss.

that got me confused pleeaeeese help...

In reply to ishaan biswas

Re: capacitor tricky

by Chandni Bhatia -

Ishaan ,I do not understand why it should discharge . Battery is a supplier of potential difference and this creates electric field which makes charges to flow ,therefore capacitor should get charged. The wires connecting the capacitor may have some resistance ,since practically you cannot have  resistance less wires.If this is the case then it is same as process of charging a capacitor.

In reply to Chandni Bhatia

Re: capacitor tricky

by ishaan biswas -

well i did not mention any battery

 also the capacitor is initially full charged

THERE IS NO BATTERY

In reply to ishaan biswas

Re: capacitor tricky

by Shashank Todwal -
At first sight anybody will say that it would get discharged.But on further digging in the problem,"nothing happens" is the answer.
This is because in a fully charged capacitor +ve and -ve charges attract each other and stay on the inner surfaces only.
When you connect only capacitor,you mean that you are connecting outer uncharged surfaces only (isn't it?).So no charge flows in circuit.

And you are absolutely correct man!!
In reply to Shashank Todwal

Re: capacitor tricky

by ishaan biswas -

well actually this is relly tricky

as what actually happens is that it instantaneously discharges.

the reason is:: after connecting te outer surfaces  it becomes oly one conductor(as the potential at the two outer suyrfaces has to bec om same) thus it instantaneously discharges.

i also wud like to ask u another questoin  if u have the archive cud u pleez explain me a certain question based on earthing a capacitor and stuff .it appeared in screening 1999. if u cant find it ill tell u the ques

In reply to ishaan biswas

Re: capacitor tricky

by Chandni Bhatia -
Ishaan, I think you are correct.Charge will continue to flowe till potentials are equal and then no flow of chrges will take place.
In reply to Shashank Todwal

Re: capacitor tricky

by Manoj Tirukodi Radhakrishn -

Todwal u need a doctor,dont talk rubbish and confuse others.

The only thing happening here is an instantaneous discharge. Otherwise gauss has to be killed for his gauss law.