Physics, Chemistry, Maths Forum

a paradox????

a paradox????

by ishaan biswas -
Number of replies: 4

consider two wires infinitely long   one placed along the x axis and the other along the y axis ata dist a above the x axis. i hope u can picturise it well because its very essental.

the horizontal one carries a curent in the +ve x dir. and the vertical one carries current in the +ve y dir.

now the vertical wire exp. a force to the right (due to other wire)  but the vertical one will not experience any force.

isnt newtons third law violated???

In reply to ishaan biswas

Re: a paradox????

by karthik vs -

when i worked out using flemings left hand rule, i found that both the wires were experiencing forces, the vertical one has a force towards the right and the horizontal one had a force upward - in the +ve y direction! i hope i understood ur question correctly, if not pls correct me!

In reply to karthik vs

Re: a paradox????

by ishaan biswas -
well i think u didnt get the question correctly.there is sopme ditance between the wires so there is  no file due to the vertical wire in the region of the horizontal one!!!1
In reply to ishaan biswas

Re: a paradox????

by karthik vs -
i think even if there is some distance between the two wires, there will be a field due to the vertical wire on the horizontal wire in the downward direction! how can u say that there will be no field in the place of the horizontal wire? do u mean to say that the field due to an infinite wire will be at the positions which are directly on its side and not some distance below it? i dont think so- the field will be zero only along the y axis, and all the surrounding regions will experience some value of the field! so the horizontal wire will experience a field whose downward component will make it experience a force!
In reply to karthik vs

Re: a paradox????

by ishaan biswas -

im sorry i didnt frame the question correctly which i had in mind.

here it is

consider a point directly under the vertical wire ,then tell me the forces acting on that specific point due to the vertical wire and vice verse